The Inside Scoop : 10 of the Best Ice Creams in San Francisco

10 of the best ice creams in San Francisco

I love ice cream but don’t often eat it at home. When I go on holiday however, it’s a completely different story. I eat as many ice creams as I can get my hands on and more than make up for all the iced delights I never eat on home turf. If you love ice cream, you’re going to love San Francisco, it really is an ice cream lover’s delight.

I was so ice cream inspired after my visit to the Museum of Ice Creamthat I committed myself to an ice-cream-a-day for the duration of my stay. As meal replacement diets go, it’s not especially healthy but it is totally delicious. I took the greatest pleasure doing my research and it gives me unbridled joy to present to you my favourite “Scoops of San Francisco.”

1. Shakedown 835 Geary Street

This downtown ice cream parlour serves small batch, handmade, artisan ice cream plus a huge range of shakes and sorbets. Even the freshly made waffle cones and bowls are handmade. The murals are as vibrant as the flavours and the service is top notch. Don’t leave town without trying the Crackerjack; Popcorn Infused Ice Cream with Swirls of Dulce De Leche and Crushed Peanut Brittle.

8 places to eat and drink in downtown San Francisco

Crackerjack

2. Swensen’s 1999 Hyde Street

For me, a visit to San Francisco is not a visit to San Francisco without a visit to Swensen’s. This is the ice chain’s original store and it’s been serving cones of delight since 1948.

Swensens - 10 ice creams to eat in San Francisco

It’s worth walking up hills to the place “where happiness never melts.” I think Olaf would approve! There’s no seating and no scoops on show, just grab your cone, cup or sundae and go.

Swensens ice cream

Caramel Turtle Fudge

3. Over The Moon 4 Embarcadero Centre, just behind the Hyatt Hotel

Here you’ll find a choice of 24 homemade ice creams and cookies like grandma used to make, plus really friendly staff to boot. If you want something more creative than a cone, you can opt for a custom ice cream sandwich or sundae instead, there are heaps of cookies and toppings to choose from. You can try before you buy and although there are no seats in the compact, modern interior, there are plenty of tables outside which are the perfect place for a spot of people watching and, if you’re lucky some free street entertainment.

over the moon ice cream 1

Caramel Cookie Dough

4. Miyako Old Fashioned Ice Cream  1470 Fillmore Street

A visit to this old skool ice cream shop and candy store is  a treat, and that’s without even taking a taste! Go inside and take a step back in time with ice cream, candies and service from today and yesteryear.

Miyako Ice Cream Parlour - The scoops of San Francisco

Tom the owner is as sweet as the ice cream he scoops and is happy to let you sample. The candies and ice cream flavours on offer are mind bogglingly good. It’s just like the good old days only better!

Miyako Ice Cream Parlour 1 - The scoops of San Francisco

Claire’s Pie (coffee, fudge, almonds, choc chips and graham cracker chunks)

5. Smitten Ice Cream 2404 California Street and other locations

Smitten is a scoop apart from other creameries because they use liquid nitrogen to freeze each scoop to order! There’s a menu but no ice cream at the counter, so once you pick your flavour, your Brrrista pours fresh cream into the Brrr machine and then the magic happens, right there in front of you! Apparently, Smitten’s founder, Robyn Sue Fisher worked with a retired aero-space engineer to design and build the first version of the Brrr, the space age machine that freezes the ice cream – it’s really is super cool in every sense.

10 San Francisco Ice Creams - Smitten

In just a couple of minutes, you’ll be eating fresh, creamy and uber delicious ice cream, ideally in one of the homemade waffle cones that are made in house and fresh every day and are utterly delicious! There’s limited seating inside and a cute little courtyard where you can savour your scoop. This place has it all, a cool store, friendly staff and quality ingredients – this is one scoop you won’t want to miss!

10 San Francisco Ice Creams - Smitten 2

Cookie Dough with Pretzels and Chocolate Chips

6. Humphry Slocombe 1 Ferry Building and other locations

If you hear someone talk of San Francisco and ice cream in the same sentence, the name they’re likely to drop is Humphry Slocombe. This San Fransiscan ice cream institution is famous for it’s wacky but wonderful flavour combinations. Located in the Ferry Building, a scoop of Slocombe is just the ticket after a day on the bay.

the scoops of SF - Humphry Slocombe

In store you’ll find a long line and a dozen diverse flavours but I’m an ice cream conservative so I played it safe with Peanut Butter Swirl. As delicious as it was, I have frozen FOMO because my SF friends tell me a signature scoop of Secret Breakfast –  with bourbon, yes bourbon, and cornflakes – is not to be missed. Whatever flavour you get, take your ice cream outside and enjoy it with a bayside view!

Humphrey Slocombe 1

Peanut Butter Fudge Ripple

7. The Baked Bear 2824 Jones Street and other locations

Located in a side street just off the strip that is Fisherman’s Wharf, this open air cafe has something for everyone – from ice cream sandwiches to sundaes and cookie bowls to floats.

The Baked Bear - Ice Cream Sandwich

Choc Chip Cookie Sandwich with Salted Caramel Ice Cream

There’s 13+ ice creams to choose from but the ice cream sandwiches are the star of the show here, you can customise your combo with cookies, donuts or brownies! There’s a ton of toppings on offer and you can even get your sandwich hot pressed too! The staff are friendly and there’s some outside seating which is always a bonus.

The Baked Bear - Ice Cream Sandwich 2

8. Three Twins Ice Cream 254 Fillmore Street

At one of the bricks and mortar stores of this local chain, you’ll find a delicious dozen of organic ice cream flavours. There’s nowhere to sit, so just grab your cone (or take a tub) and go.

3 Twins Ice Cream

Banana Nut Confetti

9. Little Giant Ice Cream 214 Sutter Street

Here you’ll find scoops that are spun in Oakland and served in San Fran in the heart of the financial district. Billed as the smallest scoop shop in America, it’s certainly cosy and serves twelve tantalising and really rather offbeat flavours, ranging from Vegan Thai Green Curry to Hot Buttered Rum.

Little Giant Ice Cream 1

Mint Brownie

There are plenty of vegan options, sorbets and there’s even pup pops, so that your dog can get the inside scoop too! The store is too small for seats, but you can perch on the multicoloured stools outside on Claude Lane.

10. Lappert’s 689 Bridgeway, Sausalito

Once an outpost of a Hawaiian chain, Lappert’s now manufactures it’s ice cream in Richmond, California. Here in the heart of Sausalito, you’ll find long lines, brisk service and a whole range of fabulous flavours. As well as scoops, there’s also shakes, sundaes and sandwiches and sugar free and frozen yoghurt options too.

Lappert's Ice Cream

Minty Cookie (Peppermint Ice Cream and Oreo Cookies)

Are you an ice cream lover too? What’s your favourite flavour? Have you got any San Franciscan ice cream that I must add to the list? What’s the one food you can’t get enough of when you go overseas?

Linking up with  VanMarcellaLauren and Isabel for Wanderful Wednesday

  • Lorelle Catalano

    Great post Sam. Wow you got me at the cookie sandwich with salted caramel ice cream. That looks amazing!! #WanderfulWednesday
    Lorelle 🙂

  • Lorraine @ Not Quite Nigella

    Oh Sammie you didn’t try Bi-rite? It’s SO good! 😀 Next time!

    • No, I didn’t make it out there but I did try some in the diner at the Museum of Ice Cream (I was so excited I inhaled it before I could take a photo). But I’m saving that and a few more for next time, because there will be a next time 🙂

  • I love this post and all the pics made me crave ice cream now! The peanut butter fudge
    ripple looks divine. 🍦 I also treat myself to lots of ice cream when I travel … it is just the best holiday companion.

  • Drool! These al really do look and sound so delicious! Take me there….!!!

  • You reminded me I haven’t had ice cream in quite some time (I have been avoiding processed food for more than a month). Here in LA we have Salt&Straw (the Portland born business). It is delicious but the lines to get a cone are a bit crazy. #wanderfulwednesday

    • I have to be honest when I’m at home, I usually avoid processed food (or at least try to,) but what I eat on vacation, stays on vacation!

  • Ooh yum! I would be all over that ice cream cookie sandwich! Those were my favorite growing up! Been years since I had one! #WanderfulWednesday

    • That ice cream sandwich was epic! The server told me that brownie/choc chip cookie is the most popular custom sandwich combination but it seemed just one step too far 🙂

  • Heeeelllooo heaven! Ice cream can do no wrongs and you found some pretty amazing scoops!

  • Foodie heaven!! I love when places let you sample the ice-cream first – especially when the flavours are so exotic! Don’t think I’ve ever stumbled upon popcorn flavored ice-cream before but would sure love to give it a try 🙂

  • Oooh Smitten looks so cool! I love the term Brrrrista hahaha – also the pun in your post title ;P

  • merilyn

    I like me an ice cream, especially whilst on holidays! … thanks sammie!
    apparently it is very good to lick and ice cream in a cone, as it is soothing and takes one back to being a baby!
    all for that! mmm!
    lolmxx

    • Now I know why I always have my ice cream in a cone, a cup just won’t cut it! I always knew I was a big baby! You know what’s what 🙂

  • You have some strong ice cream game! So I’ve tried one on this list.. I guess I have another 9 to go!